I received a message from a non-subscriber to the list who wished to post his comments. Unfortunately, my instructions regarding how to join the list must have gotten garbled as his message only came to me. I have subscribed him manually and am posting his message here manually as well, to save him from having to re-type it. ----- Original Message ----- From: Jim Capelle <JCapelle@email.msn.com> To: James Purchase <jpurch@interlog.com> Sent: Saturday, July 31, 1999 9:18 AM Subject: Re: AGA Contest Discussion List > Well folks I am sorry if I did what I think I did----I asked James P. > for a direct E-mail address so I could put my one cent into the discussion. > I was told to just hit reply-- ok I did I hope I didn't send the whole days > worth of mailings back to you all,(something that only happens to the APD > ~(:>) right!). > What I wanted to bring up is; what happens when someone like myself > works with setting true Bio-systems, like now I am working three tanks with > brackish systems to see which plants can take salt and how much. I could > never get into the WOW class to compete with an over planted system. > Then there was that talk of plastic stuff (Not Plastic Plants Please!!!) > in tanks. In the Florida State Fair every year there is a large show of > Aquarium Beautiful, there are many classes (up until this year they had > brackish systems) but they had it so the new kids in school could put > entries in and one of the class was novelties, yes novelties can be in a a > planted tank. I have a 75 gal planted tank that has 5 goldfish ( show fish > of course), my stepchild asked if I would put a plastic diver in the tank, > as I am a diver also. I agreed and now I have four plastic and four glass > divers in there. People who come to the house that also set up and show > fish love the set up, (I think they like that I have plants that work in a > goldfish tank so well) The point is if you make this showing too purest you > will run out of people and systems to show off, with out the newbies and > kids coming up and being unable to show something interest will died in a > slow dead. That's like a religion that will not allow sex will not > reproduce and pass away without a sound( anyone think of the Shakers on this > one?) > Another thing what about someone who works in the industry from getting > plants from their place of employment and setting up a tank just for the > picture that day? I ve seen that happen at Pets 96, 98. Where growers will > set up great tanks for that weekend. I ve also seen set-ups make for Fl > State Fair and the local fish shows ( 2 clubs). Will there be a break down > from class or divisions? > Ok now I ve slipped my ten cents in I leave for awhile. JiM C. ------------------ To unsubscribe from this list, e-mail majordomo@aquatic-gardeners.org with "unsubscribe aga-contest" in the body of the message. To subscribe to the digest version, add "subscribe aga-contest-digest" in the same message. Old messages are available at http://lists.thekrib.com/aga-contest