I feel this whole tirade may be simply because I stated my views more strongly than is consistent with those views. In my original posting, I explained why I did not want to use algae eaters of any kind. Gomberg suggested I try Siamese algae eaters, anyway. When I restated my reasons, perhaps more nastily than necessary, I was attacked visciously, simply because I didn't do as "ordered" by his Lord High Counsel. I am not unequivicolly opposed to the use of any kind of algae eater. I simply prefer not to run the risk, however minimal, of a repeat disaster. However, a few of you have confirmed that attacks do occasionally occur, with any species of this group. I used Venezualan Ramshorns with apistos, angels, and killies in the early eighyys, and never had a problem with them attacking eggs. That is what I am going to try again. They actually are quite small, and do not really have the bite to harm eggs, to the best of my experience. By the way, I found and they are kicking algae butt for two days now. I would really like to find a means to control phosphates in my tanks, as this is the real culprit in algae blooms. I will eventuially come up with that answer, and then will either keep or get rid of the snails. IdMiamiBob