I only add regualar amquel, novaqua, marine salt, and now and then cichlid vital. I have 3 tanks with africans, then 1 tank with guppies,neons, corys, do-jo's, then 1 with goldies. I use the same products on all tanks except no cichlid vital on guppies or goldies. Have been doing it this way for about 6 years now. Just started using marine salt about a year ago. For cost, and suposedly has more minerals than cichlid salt.Do weekly water changes from tap, {with a python}, of about 50% on all tanks{ 5 total, range from 5 gal to 125 gal}. Have also read the salt helps wth slime coating... Trish --- Kate Breimayer <kate@munat.com> wrote: > Hi, > I don't know if the fish need any additions to their > slime coat, seems > like making more slime is a sign of irritation. I > don't know, I just > don't trust any company offering remedies for > conditions I am not aware > exist. I do see a need for slime coat protection if > you are physically > handling a large fish to do some vet procedure on it > but my tetras or > rasboras, I don't know if they need anything like > that. Don't know if my > fish are any better off than anyone elses though. > I use salt in all my tanks though, it's supposed to > help with the > osmotic functions of various membranes including the > gills leading to > reduced stress and seems to keep ich and oodinium > down. I use a 12 > gallon bin to age water with 4 tbsp pure salt > (pickling salt, which has > no anti clumping agents) and 1 tsp marine aquarium > salt for added > minerals. My tap water is very soft/acid and the > minerals help both fry > and plants. If you are on a hard water system that > would be unnecessary. > Lately I have been adding some harder water fish to > the fishroom and > making up a bin with 4 tsp marine salt and a tbsp of > cichlid salt from > The Cichlid Exchange in Portland. It's an experiment > really, all my > guppies and endlers were coming out female so > thought I would play with > minerals and temp and see if I can get the ratio > improved. Anyone have > feedback on that? The genetics of sex determination > in livebearers are > really weird, it's not an XX or XY thing, it's a YY, > WX, WY etc weird > thing where three different combos produce females > and two produce > males. So what makes a swordtail a girl or a boy? > According to various > universities it makes a great thesis project as > nobody really knows... > I found a funny site parodying all the miracle > products in various fish > stores/websites. You would not believe some of the > stuff that gets > pushed down the throats of people. We had a guy send > us hundreds of > dollars in miracle products from Texas. We didn't > order but signed for > them so he threatened to sue if we didn't pay. > Promised to add > beneficial bacteria to marine and freshwater tanks > and eliminate losses. > Tried it and lost whole tanks of fish. It has a lot > of debris in it and > is light brown, no ingredients are listed except > "Bacteria". This stuff > is garbage, and there is a lot of garbage on the > market so I try and > keep it simple. Neutralize the chlorine, add known > ingredients like salt > and minerals, and lay off the sauce. > This is the site with the parody, also has some > funny puns at the end, > or should I say "finny" puns: > http://www.geocities.com/CapeCanaveral/Hangar/6279/ComicFunnyStories.html > Kate > > Trish wrote: > > >Amquel has come out with something new Calked > "Amquel > >Plus" this is what smells really bad. The regular > >"Amquel" which now I have found only from Dr Foster > >and Smith, and only in 1 gal size, doesn't smell > bad. > >The Amqel Plus has other added bacteria, which says > it > >is benificial to your fish....well it killed mine. > So > >I am back to regular Amquel....have been using it > for > >6 years, no problems. > > > >No Kate, do you use anything for slime coat as > well? > >Like Nov Aqua? Which goes with the Amquel.....LOL > > > >Trish > > > >PS How large does this Beckett product come? Also > do > >you know the price? > >--- Kate Breimayer <kate@munat.com> wrote: > > > > > > > >>I personally hate amquel, wouldn't recommend it. I > >>use a pond > >>dechlorinator from Home despot. If you are using > >>chlorinated water the > >>chemical that neutralizes it is very cheap and > >>easily available and > >>there is no reason you should have to use high > doses > >>of any product or > >>extra ingredients to achieve the aim of > >>neutralizing, and pond products > >>are 2 to 4 times as concentrated as those for > >>aquariums, come in bigger > >>bottles for the same price, and have identical > >>ingredients in most > >>cases. Some of the products out there can be > >>dangerous in some peoples' > >>hands, especially those that use amquel instead of > >>doing water changes > >>(because it says on the bottle "removes ammonia, > >>nitrite and nitrate" > >>which has never been my experience.) Also Amquel > >>smells really bad. > >>PAT is good. > >>According to a Jemco.com many cities are being > >>required by federal law > >>to switch to chloramine which is more difficult > to > >>remove, you will > >>need a special neutralizer for that. If they do it > >>they are not required > >>to tell you, scary, or it might be in the paper > but > >>if you don't read > >>the news... bad deal. > >>I age most of my water 2 days to allow gasses to > >>escape, temp to rise, > >>and chlorine to dissipate. I only use cold water > >>since supposedly it has > >>less dissolved metals/contaminants. I don't have > >>space to age water for > >>the really large tanks, hence the use of the Home > >>Despot product. The > >>Home Depot stuff is by "Beckett" and I have not > had > >>any problems with > >>it, let me know if anyone knows bad things about > it! > >>I see it also works > >>on chloramine so I am covered far as that goes. It > >>doesn't list > >>ingredients but does say it removes some heavy > >>metals. Guess we wouldn't > >>know would we? > >>Congrats on the python, no sense herniating discs > >>over a simple water > >>change! The cost of the python is quickly recouped > >>in cancelled trips to > >>massage and chiropractic specialists! :) Not to > >>mention expensive > >>physical therapy... > >>Kate > >> > >>Stewart, Jeffrey wrote: > >> > >> > >> > >>>I think I'm using Amquel currently, and I add it > in > >>> > >>> > >>as I'm refilling. I figure out approximately how > >>much I need to add and then add it in thirds as > the > >>tank slowly tops off. > >> > >> > >>>Your back will thank you for getting the > python... > >>> > >>>Jeff Stewart > >>> > >>>-----Original Message----- > >>>From: gsas-member-bounces@thekrib.com > >>> > >>> > >>[mailto:gsas-member-bounces@thekrib.com] On Behalf > >>Of A JACOBSON > >> > >> > >>>Sent: Monday, December 06, 2004 12:55 PM > >>>To: gsas-member@thekrib.com > >>>Subject: [GSAS-Member] Using a Python > >>> > >>>So, I'm about to break down and buy a python -- > or > >>> > === message truncated === __________________________________ Do you Yahoo!? Take Yahoo! Mail with you! Get it on your mobile phone. http://mobile.yahoo.com/maildemo _______________________________________________ GSAS-Member mailing list GSAS-Member@thekrib.com http://lists.thekrib.com/mailman/listinfo/gsas-member